Is Sitting the New Smoking?

February 9, 2021

One could almost get the impression that it would be safer to smoke than to sit at your desk and work. But is this true?

By Cindy Williams, RN

Coordinator, Health Ministries



“Sitting is the new smoking.” Dr. James Levine coined this phrase roughly fifteen years ago. Dr. Levine also said “Sitting is more dangerous than smoking, kills more people than HIV and is more treacherous than parachuting. We are sitting ourselves to death.” Media coverage of this and other statements from scientists looking at the effects of the sedentary lifestyle of most Americans has been widespread and intense. One could almost get the impression that it would be safer to smoke than to sit at your desk and work.

 

But is this true? A recent meta-analysis of studies on sedentary behavior compared to smoking says the answer is no. Sitting is not the new smoking. Smoking is known to cause more than 2,000 excess deaths per 100,000 people per year from any cause while people who sit the most have 190 excess deaths per 100,000 persons per year. Smoking is also highly addictive and creates the risk for secondhand exposure.

 

That doesn’t mean that sitting has no associated risks. It does. Sitting for more than eight hours a day compared with less than four hours a day is associated with some poor health outcomes. Cardiovascular disease, cancer and depression occur somewhat more frequently in those who sat the most. The most significant adverse outcome appears to be a doubling of the risk of type 2 diabetes. 

 

The news reports of some of the early studies on sitting and health seemed to indicate that you were doomed to poor health if you sat a lot. You couldn’t do anything to change the outcome. That’s kind of discouraging if you have a desk job!

 

A 2017 study in Norway demonstrated that this is probably not the case. Their findings showed an increase in the risk of diabetes only in people who were physically inactive. Their definition of physical inactivity was less than or equal to two hours of light activity and no vigorous activity each week. They compared these to people who got at least three hours of light activity and any amount of vigorous activity per week.

 

The real problem is that a very large portion of the population not only sits a lot but doesn’t engage in any physical activity. What about you? How much have you moved this week?

 

References

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7387807/

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00125-016-4193-z


This article is part of a continuing series of health during these COVID times. For other articles, please see www.uccsda.org/healthministries.


Photo by Devon Divine on Unsplash

News

By Dustin Jones • November 10, 2026
Introducing the Pifher and Christensen Endowment Fund for Campers
By Isaac Meythaler • November 10, 2026
Shine 104.9 (KEEH) raised $317,272 during their annual Fall Sharathon event the last week of October 2026, surpassing the local Christian radio station’s $300,000 goal.
By Isaac Meythaler • November 8, 2026
On September 12, 2026, the Spokane Valley Adventist Church celebrated 30 years in their current church facility in the Spokane Valley.
By Isaac Meythaler • November 3, 2026
North Pacific Union is now home to two of the thirteen 2026 Junia Award winners, with one in Upper Columbia Conference, and the other in Oregon Conference. The Junia Award is given annually by Association of Adventist Women to one woman in a pastoral role in each division.
By Contributed Report • November 2, 2026
At this year’s annual UCC Prayer Summit, titled “Almost Home,” 133 people set their sights upon heaven. The prayer retreat, held at Camp MiVoden on October 2, provided a formative faith experience, featuring inspiring prayer stories, engaging seminars, and pervasive prayer.
By Eric Brown • October 27, 2026
Early on Tuesday morning, October 13 a fire sparked at East Wenatchee Adventist Church. The fire started in the cradle roll Sabbath School room and, miraculously, did not spread further.
The cabin was looking out over the tree tops.
By Stefanie Brimacomb • October 19, 2026
An unexpected journey of faith, answered prayer, and a home we never imagined
By Dustin Jones • October 14, 2026
Gordon Pifher, former vice president of administration for Upper Columbia Conference, passed away early Friday morning, October 9, after a brief illness.
By Brenda Ermshar • October 13, 2026
The Spokane Complex fires sparked a desire in the administration at Upper Columbia Academy Elementary School (UCAES) to help those in need.
By David Jamieson • October 7, 2026
Reaching our communities in 2027